November 7, 2024

IP in a Partnership: Who Owns What?

I talk a lot here about aspects of intellectual property law. It’s an area I find pretty fascinating because it has to do with how a society encourages people to create, and the law embodies beliefs about how to accomplish that. I also talk a lot about partnership disputes which, along with IP work, forms a big part of my practice. 

Sometimes, when you put two good things together you get something great (Reese’s!). Other times, though, you just get a mess. (Melted chocolate in your pocket? OK, I’ll stop now.) Often, it’s my job to sort out the issues created when partnership disagreements intertwine with intellectual property issues — specifically, who owns a company’s IP when a partnership falls apart.

In such disputes, there are a few rules that usually apply. I’ve found these are often unknown to or misunderstood by the people involved in these scenarios. So let’s run through them.

1. Just because two people or a larger group didn’t formally register a company doesn’t mean there isn’t a partnership. In New York (where I primarily practice) and in other states, courts can find that people entered into a partnership even if they never filed paperwork to create a business entity. There are a range of factors that can come into play here but, in general, courts will look at whether the parties shared the business’s profits and losses; jointly managed or controlled the business; contributed money to the business; and/or whether they intended to be partners. Why does this matter? Because, during the existence of a partnership, the partners owe each other fiduciary duties, meaning they must treat each other fairly and, importantly, no individual member of the company can claim the company’s property for herself.

2. Thus, even if a partner registers a partnership’s trademark in her or his name, that trademark belongs to the partnership — not to her. For example, if a business operates under or sells a product with a name and/or logo, one of the members of the business can’t take ownership of that name or logo by individually obtaining a trademark registration for it. Nor can they exclude other members of the business from using the name or logo if the partnership breaks up.

3. Copyright rules are different! Generally speaking, a copyright vests in the creator, not the company. This means that if partners (either individually or together) create a work that is copyrighted or copyrightable, the copyright goes to the creator or creators, not the business. Moreover, under copyright law, transferring a copyright requires a written document, so if any owner wants to transfer a copyrighted work from themselves to the business, they need to have a document that says so.

4. On a related note, just because something is created by a partner under the auspices of the business doesn’t mean it’s a “work for hire” and thus belongs to the business from the moment of its creation. Something only becomes a work for hire in two situations: (a) if it’s prepared by an employee within the scope of his or her employment; or (b) if there’s a signed written agreement stating that the material is a work for hire.

5. Finally, the idea for a business is usually not protectable because, in general, ideas are not protectable intellectual property (I know, that sounds counterintuitive). Copyright law protects the expression of an idea, not the idea itself. So if you say to a friend, “Hey, we should open a business making ice cream for cats,” and your friend goes out and starts up Kitty Kreameries, you’re not entitled to any ownership of it. You have to put in the work and actually do the thing, not just think of the thing.  

No one starts a business with others expecting things to turn sour. But it happens a LOT. So the overall lesson here: If you’re entering into or already in a business with others, whether you’ve formally created it or not, be aware what belongs to you and what belongs to the business as a whole so you won’t be taken by surprise if it all comes crashing down someday.